Can tenants refuse a rent increase?

When renting a property, a tenant is liable to pay monthly rent to the landlord as per the rental agreement terms. Rental rates are subject to change. That is, the rent in a particular locality may vary due to several factors, such as supply-and-demand dynamics and other market forces. Landlords have the right to raise rents to align with current market rates and rising property-related costs, including taxes and maintenance. For the tenant, a rent increase may add to their financial burden. At the same time, tenants must adhere to the terms and conditions of the rental agreements, including the rent increase clause. But does a tenant have the right to refuse a rent increase? If yes, in which scenarios? Let’s find out.

When is a rent increase considered valid?

In India, landlords have the legal right to raise the rent of their property under certain conditions and in compliance with applicable rental laws. We discuss some reasons landlords raise rents. 

• Rental renewal: Upon the termination of the rental agreement, a landlord has the right to revisit the rental terms and revise the rent for the subsequent term based on market trends. This ensures they get a fair rental return and do not incur any loss. 
• Periodic tenancy: This applies to month-to-month or year-to-year tenancy arrangements, which are common in most cities in India. Landlords can determine rent increases at the end of each period as per the rental laws. It is usually a specified percentage of the annual rent. 
• Escalation clauses: Some rental agreements have an escalation clause. Under such provisions, the timing and amount of the rent hike are predetermined. It helps landlords revise rents to align with current market conditions.
• Renovation or upgrades: Rental values are based on property’s condition and related factors. If a landlord has undertaken major renovations to the house, it may increase the property’s value. In such cases, they can increase the rent provided they meet the legal requirements.

When can a tenant refuse a rent increase?

Tenants’ rights are governed by the tenancy laws and state-level rental control acts. Tenants can refuse in the following scenarios:

Violation of the rental laws

Landlords can increase the rent only in accordance with the local rental laws. The maximum rent increase allowed by a landlord is determined by the rent control law of the specific state. These laws are designed according to the local residential market conditions and other socio-economic factors. 

For example, in states like Delhi and Karnataka, annual rent increases are typically up to 10%, while in Maharashtra, they are up to 4%. By capping rent increases, the government aims to prevent unreasonable increases and maintain a balance, allowing landlords to receive fair rental returns while safeguarding tenants’ rights. In the event of any violation, the tenant can refuse to pay the increased rent.

Breach of the rental agreement 

There must be a valid rental agreement in place when a property owner rents to a tenant. It ensures a legal framework for governing the relationship between the landlord and tenant. The rental agreement should clearly state the amount of rent the tenant is liable to pay, the payment timelines and schedule, duration of tenancy, security deposit and refund terms, etc. Moreover, the conditions for the rent increase should be clearly mentioned in the agreement. This gives clarity to the tenant and prevents potential disputes. However, if the rent increase is unfair and violates the rental agreement, the tenant has the right to act against the landlord. 

One example is increasing the rent mid-tenure without notice. If this is not mentioned in the agreement, it is a clear indication that the landlord is violating the rental agreement, and the tenant can refuse to pay a higher amount.

Absence of a rent hike clause

Similarly, in the absence of any clause in the rent agreement regarding rent increase, a tenant can refuse to pay higher rent. The landlord must ensure that the relevant clause governing rent hikes. If it is not included or if there are vague clauses, the tenant is not liable to pay an increased rent, even if the landlord requests it.

What can tenants do in case of an unfair rent increase?

Here are the steps a tenant can take if their landlord has imposed an unfair rent hike.

Negotiation

If a tenant finds the landlord’s rent increase unreasonable, they can politely refuse. It is better to reply in writing to ensure the conversation is documented, which will serve as proof in case of disputes. Tenants should be aware of their legal rights and local rental laws, which will put them in a better position during negotiations. 

Ask for improved services in return

Tenants and landlords can mutually agree on the rent increase. To safeguard their interests, tenants can request improved maintenance of the rented property, such as upgrades or services, in return. For example, tenants can ask for additional parking space, a storage facility or upgraded appliances. This arrangement will be beneficial for both the tenant and the landlord. 

Seek a written notice 

Before agreeing to a rent increase, tenants can ask the landlord for a market rate comparison. If they are not satisfied, they can refuse to pay the higher rent. However, it is important to document everything, including a revised rental agreement. 

File a compliant

In the event of a dispute with the landlord over an unfair rent increase, tenants can seek legal recourse. They can approach the rent authority in their state and register their concerns. Tenants must ensure they have valid proof, including the rental agreement copy. 

Approach a lawyer

Tenants can also approach an experienced lawyer and sue the landlord in a consumer court for the unfair rent increase. In such cases, the court may ask the landlord to withdraw their request for a hike, reduce the hike, or pay penalties, if applicable.

Consequences of refusing a valid rent increase

While the laws are there to protect the tenant’s rights, they also keep a check on tenants’ by laying down responsibilities and duties. This helps protect the landlord’s rights. Refusing to pay a fair rent increase can result in legal consequences for tenants. 

• Strain in landlord-tenant relationship: By failing to comply with the tenancy agreement, a tenant who refuses to pay the increased rent is possibly causing strain in the landlord-tenant relationship. It could lead to a loss of goodwill and a clear track record. 
• Eviction: If the rent increase complies with the rent agreement and rental laws, and the tenant has refused to pay the increased rent, the landlord may issue an eviction notice.

Housing.com News Viewpoint

The maximum rent increase a landlord can charge is often regulated by state rental laws. However, if the rent hikes are unreasonable and violate the Rent Control Act limits, tenants can refuse to pay the increased rent. Moreover, if the hike is against the existing rental agreement terms or there is no proper notice or valid reasons by the landlord, they can refuse the rent increase. On the other hand, if the increase is legally permissible and clearly stated in the agreement, tenants must comply with the same to avoid legal action by the landlord. However, they can negotiate a revision based on mutual agreement. It is crucial for landlords and tenants to be aware of the local tenancy laws, maintain clear communication in writing and review rent clauses before signing an agreement. This will help prevent disputes.

FAQs