How to differentiate between potting mix and potting soil effectively

For the newbie gardener, venturing into the world of growing mediums can be confusing. Two terms, potting mix and potting soil, are often used interchangeably, but there’s a key difference between them. Understanding this distinction is crucial for choosing the perfect environment for your potted plants to thrive. In this article we’ll help you understand this very difference.

Table of Contents

Potting mix: The soilless champion

Potting mix, also known as a soilless mix or medium, is exactly what the name suggests – it doesn’t contain any actual soil. Instead, it’s a carefully crafted blend of organic and inorganic materials designed to provide optimal drainage, aeration and nutrient availability for container plants. Here’s a breakdown of its key components:

Organic materials

Peat moss: A lightweight, spongy material that retains moisture well.
Coco coir: Made from coconut husks, it offers good drainage and improves aeration.
Compost: Adds essential nutrients and beneficial microbes to the mix.
Bark: Provides drainage and air pockets, crucial for healthy root development.

Inorganic materials

Perlite: A volcanic rock that provides excellent drainage and aeration.
Vermiculite: A heat-treated mica mineral that helps retain moisture.
Sand: Improves drainage and prevents compaction.

The specific ratio of these ingredients varies depending on the intended use. For instance, a cactus mix will have a higher proportion of inorganic materials for superior drainage, while a mix for moisture-loving plants like ferns will contain more peat moss for better water retention.

Benefits of potting mix

Improved drainage: Unlike garden soil, which can become waterlogged in containers, potting mix allows for excess water to drain freely, preventing root rot, a leading cause of plant death in pots.
Enhanced aeration: The inclusion of inorganic materials like perlite and vermiculite ensures proper air circulation around the roots, promoting healthy root growth and nutrient uptake.
Consistent quality: Unlike garden soil, which can vary greatly in composition, potting mix provides a consistent and predictable growing environment for your plants.
Lightweight: Potting mix is significantly lighter than garden soil, making it easier to handle and manoeuvre potted plants, especially larger ones.
Sterility: Most commercial potting mixes are sterilised during the manufacturing process, minimising the risk of introducing harmful pathogens, weed seeds or fungus gnats into your container garden.

Potting soil: A blend of benefits

Potting soil, sometimes referred to as garden soil, can be a blend of actual soil, compost and other organic materials. It’s often a more affordable option compared to potting mix. However, there are some key considerations to keep in mind.

Key features

Drainage: Regular garden soil can be heavy and prone to compaction, leading to poor drainage in containers. This can be detrimental to most container plants.
Weight: The presence of soil makes potting soil significantly heavier than potting mix, making it difficult to manage larger pots.
Sterility: Unlike potting mix, potting soil may not be sterilised, potentially introducing weeds, diseases or pests into your container garden.
Nutrient depletion: Over time, the nutrients in potting soil can become depleted, requiring more frequent fertilisation compared to potting mix.

Potting mix vs. potting soil

So, when should you choose potting mix over potting soil and vice versa? Here’s a quick guide:

Use potting mix for

All indoor container plants.
Seed starting and seedling transplants.
Outdoor container plants, including vegetables, herbs, flowers and trees.
Plants that require excellent drainage, such as cacti, succulents and African violets.

Consider potting soil for

Established outdoor container plants, especially if weight is a concern (be extra vigilant about drainage).
Amending garden beds (though not recommended for sole use in containers).

Additional tips

Read the label: Always check the ingredients list on the bag of potting mix to ensure it’s suitable for your intended plants.
Drainage is key: Regardless of your choice, ensure your container has drainage holes to prevent waterlogging.
Amending the mix: For some plants, you may need to amend the potting mix to meet their specific needs. For example, cacti and succulents may benefit from the addition of perlite for even better drainage.
Refreshing the mix: Over time, potting mix can break down and lose its effectiveness. Repot your plants in a fresh potting mix every 1-2 years.

By understanding the distinctions between potting mix and potting soil, you can help your plants thrive to the best of their ability.

FAQs

What's the difference between potting mix and potting soil?

Potting mix is a soilless blend of organic and inorganic materials designed for optimal drainage, aeration and nutrient availability in containers. Potting soil, on the other hand, can contain actual soil mixed with organic matter.

Which one drains better?

Potting mix wins the drainage battle. Its inclusion of perlite, vermiculite or bark allows excess water to escape freely, preventing root rot. Regular potting soil can be heavy and prone to compaction, leading to poor drainage in pots.

Is potting mix lighter than potting soil?

Absolutely. The lack of actual soil makes potting mix significantly lighter than potting soil. This is a big advantage when handling and manoeuvring larger containers.

Is potting mix sterile?

Most commercial potting mixes are sterilised during production, minimising the risk of introducing harmful pathogens, weeds or pests into your container garden. Potting soil, on the other hand, might not be sterilised

Which one is more affordable?

Potting soil generally comes with a lower price tag compared to potting mix. However, potting mix requires less frequent repotting due to its consistent quality and nutrient content, potentially making it more cost-effective in the long run.

When should I use a potting mix?

Potting mix is the champion for almost all container gardening situations. It's ideal for indoor plants, seed starting, outdoor container plants (vegetables, herbs, flowers, trees) and plants with high drainage needs (cacti, succulents).

Is there ever a time to use potting soil?

Consider using potting soil for established outdoor container plants, especially if weight is a concern. However, be extra vigilant about drainage. It can also be used for amending garden beds, but not recommended for sole use in containers.

Got any questions or point of view on our article? We would love to hear from you. Write to our Editor-in-Chief Jhumur Ghosh at [email protected]

Was this article useful?